Picture this: you’re walking through a museum gift shop and spot a deep blue bottle that claims its ancestors perfumed George Washington. Old-school? Absolutely. Near-mythic patience? You bet. In business since 1752, Caswell-Massey is an American survivor—older than the Fourth of July, older than the word “shampoo” in English, and old enough to see its origin city, Newport, Rhode Island, pass through major wars, fads, and several U.S. presidents wearing their fragrances.
Yet, if you spend any time on forums or reading anxious customer reviews, you have to wonder: Is Caswell-Massey finally shutting down?
Let’s pull back the curtain—myth, dust, and foamy legacy aside—to see what’s really happening.
America’s Oldest Bar Soap Brand Has Seen a Few Sunsets
Surviving centuries in the grooming game is a tall order. Just ask your local indie beard oil maker—most run out of momentum (or moustache wax) by year five.
Caswell-Massey started as a small apothecary in 1752. Back then, bar soap was new tech, and a proper cologne was rare enough to feel like magic. By one count, the original Newport shop was threading the needle between medicine and luxury—think, powdered wigs and scented tonics. Their customer base spanned John Adams to J.P. Morgan.
Through the 1800s, Caswell-Massey parlayed its “refined, American-made” image into a thriving mail-order empire. At large, the company weathered Civil War uncertainties, Prohibition, and the Great Depression. Slogans changed; recipes kept their Victorian length. Their soaps and colognes were still being handed out in presidential gift baskets by the 1980s.
But the clock never stops ticking. And this heritage—while impressive—came at a cost when trends began favoring modern brands with flashier marketing budgets and online muscle.
Financial Ups and Downs: Bankruptcy, Buyouts, and Getting Back Up
If you think an old brand is immune to modern business headaches, think again. Caswell-Massey has barreled face-first into several existential moments.
The late ’80s saw the business circling the drain. In 1989, Caswell-Massey was reportedly “days away from bankruptcy.” There’s a catch in that: legacy alone doesn’t pay invoices. The company survived that close call by cutting costs, recruiting new investors, and—crucially—selling products wherever it could (including department stores and catalogs).
Ownership ping-ponged. New investment groups, new bosses, occasional pivots. But in 2007, an investment group led by private buyers scooped up Caswell-Massey, ultimately bringing discipline and a modern facelift while keeping the old formulas alive.
For the last two decades, the brand has stayed afloat as a privately owned, boutique operation. It’s shrunken but stubborn—like the last classic diner on a block of new condos.
What’s Happening Right Now: Brick-and-Mortar, E-Commerce, and Those Online Rumors
Here’s where rumors start swirling. Yes, Caswell-Massey closed most—if not all—of its retail stores. Their old flagship shops in New York City and D.C.? Gone. But take heart: this isn’t a funeral; it’s just the next chapter of retail. The grooming industry, battered by rent hikes and e-commerce giants, is not kind to physical shops.
This has led to a flurry of whisper campaigns: Is the “America’s Original Apothecary” pulling the plug? The answer: not even close.
Instead, Caswell-Massey is betting on its website, caswellmassey.com, and a steady presence on Amazon, plus carefully curated partnerships with specialty shops and hotels. The brand is briskly selling year-round, especially during anniversary sales like its splashy “272nd birthday sale” in 2024.
Social media channels—Instagram, Facebook, YouTube—are active and professionally run. Promotions are running in August 2025, proof the company is alive, alert, and sending out orders daily. No shuttered warehouses. Just a change in era—old paper catalogs replaced by targeted email and a sharp e-commerce engine.
Industry Headwinds: What Old School Brands Need to Survive
For starters, every old brand faces the “is that still your grandpa’s soap?” problem. Heritage is gold, until it starts to gather dust. Caswell-Massey isn’t alone here: grooming brands like Yardley, Penhaligon’s, and even Crabtree & Evelyn have all overhauled their identities or shifted sales online, too.
Why close physical shops? Simple math: E-commerce margins are fatter. Physical stores bleed money when foot traffic dries up. Department stores—once the promised land for prestige brands—are increasingly unreliable, with many closing or shrinking shelf space for third-party lines.
Caswell-Massey has pivoted nimbly. By one count, they’ve refreshed packaging, re-released classic scents (such as Number Six and Newport), and unveiled limited-edition “Heritage” collections to lure in both nostalgia lovers and younger shoppers.
There’s also a growing trend toward clean ingredients—no parabens, no phthalates. Caswell-Massey highlights small-batch soapmaking and “Made in USA” sourcing. This has led to new partnerships with museums and universities—like its collaborative scent with the New York Botanical Garden.
And when you want to reach modern customers, you meet them where they scroll. Caswell-Massey’s Instagram features history, new launches, and cheeky stories about former presidents lathering up. E-commerce traffic spikes during gift-giving season—Father’s Day, holidays, even Valentine’s—and the brand responds with timely bundles and free shipping deals.
From the Horse’s Mouth: Public Statements and Consumer Clues
What do the official channels say? Nothing about shutting down—if anything, it’s the opposite. In interviews and public newsletters, Caswell-Massey’s team highlights “commitment to American craftsmanship” and “plans for new product launches.” Their emails tease collaborations and feature glowing reviews from media outlets.
If you call their customer service or DM on social media, you’ll get swift, professional answers. (Try that with a company on its last legs.) Open review sites, and you’ll still see complaints about $20 soap and love-letters to their iconic Almond or Jockey Club scents—not threads about bankruptcy.
Recent news bites: In August 2025, Caswell-Massey rolled out fresh content for its “Heritage” line, offered a buy-one-get-one deal, and retargeted lapsed customers with discount codes. That’s not what you’d expect from a company fading into the sunset—it’s what you see when a classic brand is playing for the next fifty years.
If you want to see another surviving example of smart e-commerce adaptation and business maneuvering, check out BlueLine Biz—it’s a window into how legacy and small brands turn modern pressures into growth stories.
The Path Forward: Optimism, Discipline, and What Will Keep Caswell-Massey in Business
Let’s get pragmatic. Yes, grooming and fragrance brands face brutal headwinds: upstarts with wild TikTok strategies, ever-rising costs for natural oils, customer loyalty that can turn on a dime.
But here’s what Caswell-Massey has in its corner:
1. **Deep Brand Equity**: The “America’s original apothecary” angle isn’t just marketing—it’s a moat. Loyalists buy the story along with the soap.
2. **Adaptability**: Dropping underperforming stores isn’t defeatist—it’s survival. The brand survives by cutting losses and pushing where it wins: online.
3. **Product Quality**: While $18 soap feels extravagant, the loyal customer base (often mid-career professionals or tradition-minded buyers) prefers “buy once, cry once” over impulsive, throwaway options.
4. **Serial Innovation**: New packaging, seasonal bundles, museum partnerships—it keeps the brand from feeling musty, even while Churchill-era recipes hold court in the background.
If you’re watching for red flags, you want to see missed shipments, abandoned social media, or mass inventory sell-offs. Caswell-Massey is showing—by all available signs—the opposite. No hints of cashflow crisis. No telltale “everything must go” fire sale language. In short, if you’re rooting for an American classic, you can exhale.
What We Can Learn: Business Longevity by the Bar Soap
The grooming industry is expanding—but it’s also unforgiving, and it takes discipline to win. For Caswell-Massey, survival has meant walking away from fixed costs (physical shops), doubling down where the customer responds (heritage products, nimble ecommerce), and guiding a centuries-old brand’s story into the zeitgeist.
At large, rumors swirl when legacy brands shift models or lose storefronts, but the data points in another direction: penchant for adaptation, proven ability to survive disaster, and an actual, invested presence in today’s online economy.
Will Caswell-Massey still be here in another fifty years? That depends—on how the next cohort of buyers fall for heritage and how deftly the company keeps its story and supply chain relevant.
For now, the answer to the big question—“is Caswell-Massey going out of business?”—is a resounding “nope.” The old apothecary is soapy, scrappy, and still shipping, and their future smells distinctly like survival.
Also Read
